What are we looking at?
Girls 1: Ugly ass, terrible dog. Ugly Shirt, ugly outfit. Nothing good going on for this one. Go back to your apt and stay there.
Girls 2: dog looks more alert and fun. Owner rocking out with some headphones, good arm, nice body. Wedges are decent, not the highest, but not a mini wedge either. Dress is a bit too much going on for He's liking. Based on the dog alone, she gets He's vote.
Time for the ArmHE to Vote:
Vote I Agree: Girl 1
Vote I Disagree: Girl 2